Basic overview of SSH Keys
An SSH key is an access credential in the SSH protocol. Its function is similar to that of user names and passwords, but the keys are primarily used for automated processes and for implementing single sign-on by system administrators and power users.
ContentsSSH keys are authentication credentials Authorized keys define who can access each system Identity keys identify users and provide access Certificate-based user authentication Device authentication keys Host keys authenticate servers Known host keys Session keys How to configure key-based authentication How to set up public key authentication for OpenSSH Storing keys in ssh-agent for single sign-on Recommended key sizes Identity key location Authorized key location Moving SSH keys to a root-owned location OpenSSH's limitation on the number of private keys What do SSH keys look like How does authentication in SSH work? Public key authentication How common are SSH keys and what is the risk How to eliminate SSH keys entirely
SSH keys are authentication credentials
SSH (Secure Shell) is used for managing networks, operating systems, and configurations. It is also inside many file transfer tools and configuration management tools. Every major corporation uses it, in every data center.
SSH keys enable the automation that makes modern cloud services and other computer-dependent services possible and cost-effective. They offer convenience and improved security when properly managed.
Functionally SSH keys resemble passwords. They grant access and control who can access what. In identity and access management, they need similar policies, provisioning, and termination as user accounts and passwords. One cannot have confidentiality, integrity, or any guarantees of continued availability of systems without controlling SSH keys.
Technically the keys are cryptographic keys using a public key cryptosystem. However, functionally they are authentication credentials and need to be managed as such.
Authorized keys define who can access each system
Authorized keys are public keys that grant access. They are analogous to locks that the corresponding private key can open.
For more information, see the dedicated page on authorized keys.
Identity keys identify users and provide access
Identity keys are private keys that an SSH client uses to authenticate itself when logging into an SSH server. They are analogous to physical keys that can open one or more locks.
Authorized keys and identity keys are jointly called user keys. They relate to user authentication, as opposed to host keys that are used for host authentication.
For more information, see the dedicated page on identity keys.
Certificate-based user authentication
PKI certificates can also be used for authentication. In this case, the user still has a private key but also has a certificate associated with the key. The technology is supported in both Tectia SSH and OpenSSH, with some differences.
Device authentication keys
Host keys authenticate servers
Certificate-based host authentication can be a very attractive alternative in large organizations. It allows device authentication keys to be rotated and managed conveniently and every connection to be secured.
Known host keys
One of the unique features of SSH is that by default, it trusts and remembers the host's key when first connecting to it. This was a key differentiator that allowed SSH to be deployed grass-roots, as there was no centralized key infrastructure for hosts in 1995, and still isn't today (2017), with exemption of SSL certificates for web servers. The resulting ease of deployment was one of the main reasons SSH became successful.
The memorized host keys are called known host keys and they are stored in a file called
known_hosts in OpenSSH. As long as host keys don't change, this appoach is very easy to use and provides fairly good security. However, in large organization and when the keys change, maintaining known hosts files can become very time-consuming. Using certificates for host keys is recommended in that case. Tectia SSH supports standard X.509 certificates for hosts. OpenSSH has its own proprietary certificate format. The advantage of standard-based certificates is that they can be issued by any certificate authority (CA), whereas no reliable CAs exist for OpenSSH keys.
A session key in SSH is an encryption key used for encrypting the bulk of the data in a connection. The session key is negotiated during the connection and then used with a symmetric encryption algorithm and a message authentication code algorithm to protect the data. For more information, see the separate page on session keys.
How to configure key-based authentication
Key based authentication in SSH is called public key authentication. It is easy to configure by end users in the default configuration. On the other hand, security-conscious organizations need to establish clear policies for provisioning and terminating key-based access.
How to set up public key authentication for OpenSSH
SSH keys are typically configured in an authorized_keys file in
.ssh subdirectory in the user's home directory. Typically a system administrator would first create a key using
ssh-keygen and then install it as an authorized key on a server using the
ssh-copy-id tool. See also the dedicated page on configuring authorized keys for OpenSSH.
We recommend using passphrases for all identity keys used for interactive access. In principle we recommend using passphrases for automated access as well, but this is often not practical.
Storing keys in ssh-agent for single sign-on
SSH comes with a program called
ssh-agent, which can hold user's decrypted private keys in memory and use them to authenticate logins. The agent can also be used to access keys on a smartcard or in a Hardware Security Module (HSM). See the documentation for ssh-agent on how to set it up.
The connection to the SSH agent can be forwarded to a server, so that single sign-on also works from that server onwards. That feature should be used with care, as it allows a compromised server to use the user's credentials from the original agent. Agent forwarding can, however, be a major convenience feature for power users in less security critical environments.
Recommended key sizes
We recommend selecting key sizes according to NIST SP 800-57. The default key sizes used by the
ssh-keygen tool are generally of acceptable strength. In fact, since the protocol never reveals the public keys that are acceptable for user authentication, the algorithms used for the keys are not as critical as they are in, for example, PKI certificates.
For RSA keys, 2048 bits is probably a good choice today (2017). However, many cryptographers now recommend switching to ECDSA keys and think that advances in factoring large integers may make RSA keys vulnerable in the near/mid-term. For ECDSA we recommend using 521 bit (sic!) keys, even though 384 or even 256 bit keys probably would be safe. There is just no practical benefit from using smaller keys.
Identity key location
Identity keys are usually stored in a user's
.ssh directory, for example,
.ssh/ssh_id_rsa. The default identity key file name starts with
id_<algorithm>. However, it is possible to specify any file name and any location when creating a private key, and provide the path name with the
-i option to the SSH client. For example,
ssh -i /home/ylo/secure/my-key email@example.com would use a private key from the file
my-key for authentication.
The default identity key location can also be configured in /etc/ssh/ssh_config or the user's
.ssh/config file using the
Authorized key location
When a user tries to log in using key-based authentication, the OpenSSH server looks for authorized keys from a directory specifies in the server configuration using the
AuthorizedKeysFile option. The default is
.ssh/authorized_keys in the user's home directory.
However, having the authorized keys stored in the user's home directory means that the user can add new keys that authorize logins to his/her account. This is convenient, but the user can then give these keys to friends or colleagues, or even sell them for Bitcoins (this has actually happened). SSH keys are furthermore permanent and remain valid until expressly removed.
If authorized keys are added for root or service accounts, they easily remain valid even after the person who installed them has left the organization. They are also a convenient way for hackers to establish permanent presence on a system if there is no detection and alerts about unauthorized new keys.
For these reasons, most larger organizations want to move authorized keys to a root-owned location and established a controlled provisioning and termination process for them.
Moving SSH keys to a root-owned location
In principle, moving SSH keys to a root-owned location is easy:
Create a suitable root-owned directory, e.g.,
/etc/ssh/keys, under which authorized keys are stored.
Create a subdirectory under this directory for each user, and move each user's
Finally, change set
In practice, however, this is not always so simple, especially in larger environments. User names may come from directories (e.g., Active Directory or LDAP). Many organizations have varying OpenSSH versions, including very old systems or custom SSH builds that have non-standard built-in paths. We recommend using key management tools such as Universal SSH Key Manager to hide this complexity in larger environments. These tools can also implement a provisioning, termination, and approval workflow for keys and alerts about unauthorized changes made by root users.
OpenSSH's limitation on the number of private keys
The OpenSSH server has a feature (I would call it a bug) that it counts testing whether a particular key can be used for authentication as an authentication attempt. This has the consequence that if the user has more than five keys in
.ssh, only some of them work. This often causes key-based authentication to fail and is often difficult for users to figure out. The way around this is to explicitly specify the private key to use using the
-i option. An alternative is to adjust the
MaxAuthTries session on the server, but this is not a full solution and it is undesirable to increase the number of attempts for password authentication.
What do SSH keys look like
An authorized key can look like this:
ecdsa-sha2-nistp256 AAAAE2VjZHNhLXNoYTItbmlzdHAyNTYAAAAIbmlzdHAyNTYAAABBBN+Mh3U/3We4VYtV1QmWUFIzFLTUeegl1Ao5/QGtCRGAZn8bxX9KlCrrWISIjSYAwCajIEGSPEZwPNMBoK8XD8Q= ylo@klar
An identity key can look like this:
-----BEGIN EC PRIVATE KEY----- MHcCAQEEIJWbvSW7h50HPwG+bWR3DXgQ6YhOxYbe0ifr1rRUvsUuoAoGCCqGSM49 AwEHoUQDQgAE34yHdT/dZ7hVi1XVCZZQUjMUtNR56CXUCjn9Aa0JEYBmfxvFf0qU KutYhIiNJgDAJqMgQZI8RnA80wGgrxcPxA== -----END EC PRIVATE KEY-----
How does authentication in SSH work?
Initializing a connection in SSH consists of:
Negotiating the version of the protocol to use
Negotiating cryptographic algorithms and other options to use
Negotiating a one-time session key for encrypting the rest of the session
Authenticating the server host using its host key
Authenticating the user using a password, public key authentication, or other means.
After this, data can be exchanged, including terminal data, graphics, and files.
Public key authentication
The key-based authentication mechanism in SSH is called public key authentication. Essentially, some session-specific data is signed using the private identity key. The signature is then sent to the server that checks if the key used for signing is configured as an authorized key. The server then verifies the digital signature using the public key in the authorized key. The identity key is never sent to the server.
The essential thing in public key authentication is that it allows one server to access another server without having to type in a password. This powerful feature is why it is so widely used for file transfers (using the SFTP protocol) and configuration management. It is also commonly used by system administrators for single sign-on.
How common are SSH keys and what is the risk
SSH keys turn out to be extremely common and widely used. Many large organizations have accumulated them for twenty years without any controls. A typical Fortune 500 enterprise has several million keys granting access to their servers. In one customer case, we examined 500 applications and 15,000 servers, and found 3,000,000 authorized keys and 750,000 unique key pairs. This organization also had over five million daily logins using keys. The keys were used for executing financial transactions, updating configurations, moving log data, file transfers, interactive logins by system administrators, and many other purposes.
It is turning out that most large enterprises have hundreds of thousands or even millions of keys. These keys are access that is unaccounted for, and may risk the entire enterprise.
How to eliminate SSH keys entirely
The PrivX On-Demand Access Manager can be used to eliminate SSH keys from servers entirely and establish policy-based access control and session logging across the enterprise. It also eliminates most of the administrative burden in managing keys, while still providing the benefits: automation and single sign-on.